Understanding Informal Power Structures in Community Development

You've done everything you're supposed to do.

You've developed a plan, identified the stakeholders, secured support from local leadership and received the approvals needed to move forward.

On paper, the project is ready.

But something isn't working.

Meetings keep getting postponed. Partners hesitate to commit. Questions that seemed resolved continue resurfacing.

And despite having the right people involved, the initiative isn't gaining momentum.

What if the people who can help move your project forward aren't the people listed on the organizational chart?

In Episode 39 of Thrive in Five, Sarah explores one of the most important, yet frequently overlooked, realities of community development: every community has both a formal and an informal power structure.

Understanding both can make a meaningful difference in how leaders build relationships, develop partnerships and move initiatives from planning to implementation.

Every Community Has Two Organizational Charts

Most communities have a clearly defined leadership structure.

Elected officials make policy decisions.

Agency directors oversee programs and operations.

Board chairs guide organizations.

Department heads manage responsibilities.

These individuals hold formal authority, and their roles are essential to community decision-making.

But there's another organizational chart that rarely appears in a strategic plan.

It's made up of people whose relationships, experience, reputation and community standing give them influence beyond an official position.

A longtime city employee who understands how projects have succeeded or failed across multiple administrations.

A respected business owner whose support can help bring other businesses to the table.

A family whose history and connection to the community gives its perspective particular weight.

A trusted community member who may not lead an organization but whose opinion others consistently seek.

These individuals may not have formal authority to approve a project.

But their support, concerns or willingness to participate can influence whether it gains traction.

Formal authority tells you who can approve a decision. Informal influence can help explain whether the community will support it.

Effective community development requires understanding both.

Why Formal Approval Doesn't Always Mean Community Buy-In

One of the most frustrating experiences for community leaders is watching a well-developed initiative struggle after receiving formal approval.

The funding may be secured.

The governing body may have voted in favor.

The project may align with an adopted strategic plan.

Yet implementation becomes difficult.

Why?

Sometimes the issue isn't the quality of the plan.

It's that important relationships, perspectives or concerns weren't addressed before the decision was made.

Consider a hypothetical downtown revitalization initiative.

Local officials support the project. A planning committee has reviewed the proposal, and the organization responsible for implementation is ready to begin.

But several longtime business owners have concerns about how the changes could affect customer access and daily operations.

Those concerns weren't fully explored during planning.

As the project moves forward, hesitation grows.

Other businesses begin asking questions.

What initially appeared to be broad support becomes a much more complicated conversation.

The problem may not be opposition to revitalization itself.

It may be that people with meaningful influence weren't adequately involved in shaping the approach.

A plan can have formal approval without having the relationships and trust needed for successful implementation.

That's why identifying influential community members should happen early, not after resistance emerges.

Informal Influence Looks Different in Every Community

There's no universal list of people who hold informal influence.

The dynamics depend on a community's history, relationships, institutions and culture.

In some places, influence may rest with longtime public employees who understand how local government actually operates.

They know the history behind decisions, the practical barriers to implementation and the relationships that have shaped previous projects.

In other communities, business owners may have significant influence because of their longstanding investment, professional networks or leadership within local organizations.

In rural communities, families with deep historical connections to the area may carry particular credibility.

Elsewhere, trusted neighborhood leaders, nonprofit professionals, faith leaders or community advocates may be important voices.

And influence isn't always concentrated in the same people across every issue.

Someone who is highly influential in a downtown business discussion may have little involvement in a housing initiative or workforce development project.

The goal isn't to identify a handful of powerful people and assume they speak for everyone.

It's to understand how relationships and influence operate around the particular issue you're trying to address.

That requires observation, listening and genuine engagement.

The Small Clue That Can Reveal Informal Influence

Sarah shares a particularly practical observation in Episode 39.

When a difficult question comes up during a meeting, pay attention to what happens before anyone answers.

Does everyone glance toward the same person?

Does the room become quiet until someone offers an opinion?

Do others wait for a particular individual to speak before sharing their own thoughts?

Those moments can reveal something about the group's dynamics.

As Sarah puts it:

“That glance is data.”

It may indicate whose judgment others trust, whose approval matters or whose experience carries weight.

Of course, one glance isn't enough to establish someone's influence.

But repeated patterns can provide valuable clues about the relationships shaping a conversation.

And those observations can help community leaders identify people they should get to know better.

How to Identify Informal Leaders and Influential Stakeholders

Understanding a community's informal power structure isn't about manipulating relationships or finding ways around formal decision-making.

It's about developing a more complete picture of the people, experiences and perspectives that influence community action.

Here are four ways to begin.

1. Listen More Than You Talk

When entering a new community or beginning a major initiative, it's tempting to start immediately with solutions.

You have ideas.

You've identified opportunities.

You're eager to demonstrate progress.

But the early stages of community development are also an opportunity to learn.

Listen to how people describe previous projects.

Pay attention to who is frequently mentioned.

Notice which organizations work together and where relationships may be strained.

Ask about the history behind decisions that might otherwise seem straightforward.

Understanding the community before trying to change it can help you avoid challenges that aren't visible in a project plan.

2. Ask How Previous Projects Actually Moved Forward

One of the most useful questions Sarah suggests is:

Who did the last project have to bring along before it could move?

That question can reveal the difference between the official approval process and the relationships that made implementation possible.

Perhaps a respected business leader helped build support.

Maybe a longtime community advocate raised concerns that ultimately improved the plan.

Or a trusted partner helped connect organizations that hadn't previously worked together.

These stories can provide insight into how the community approaches change.

They can also help you understand which relationships deserve attention early in your own initiative.

3. Notice Whose Opinions Carry Weight

During meetings and community conversations, observe how people respond to one another.

Whose perspective changes the direction of a discussion?

Who can bring people with different opinions together?

Who is trusted to explain complicated issues?

Who do others turn to when uncertainty arises?

These individuals may be valuable partners in understanding community concerns and building stronger initiatives.

But remember that influence and agreement aren't the same thing.

Someone who challenges your proposal may still offer important insight into what the community needs.

The objective should be understanding, not simply securing approval.

4. Build Relationships Before You Need Support

One of the biggest mistakes community leaders can make is waiting until a project is ready for approval before reaching out to influential stakeholders.

By that point, important decisions may already have been made.

People may feel that their involvement is being requested only to validate a predetermined outcome.

Instead, begin building relationships early.

Ask questions.

Invite perspectives.

Understand concerns.

Share information before major decisions are finalized.

And create opportunities for people to contribute meaningfully.

Strong partnerships are easier to build when the relationship begins before the request.

Informal Influence Shouldn't Replace Inclusive Community Engagement

There's an important distinction worth making.

Understanding informal power structures can help leaders navigate community relationships.

But influential people don't necessarily represent everyone affected by a decision.

A well-connected business owner may offer valuable insight into downtown development.

That doesn't mean their perspective replaces the experiences of downtown employees, renters, customers or other residents.

A longtime community leader may understand local history.

That doesn't mean newer residents have less valuable perspectives about the community's future.

This connects directly to Episode 37 of Thrive in Five, where Sarah challenged community leaders to consider whose voices are missing from planning processes.

Both ideas matter.

Understanding influence helps you navigate relationships. Inclusive engagement helps you make better-informed decisions.

The strongest community development strategies consider both.

Stakeholder Mapping Should Go Beyond Job Titles

Stakeholder mapping is a common part of community planning.

Organizations identify the individuals, groups and institutions connected to an initiative.

They consider who has decision-making authority, who will be affected and who should participate.

But traditional stakeholder lists can become overly focused on formal roles.

Mayor.

City manager.

Chamber president.

Economic development director.

Board chair.

Those people may be essential.

But a more complete stakeholder map also considers relationships, trust, community standing and informal influence.

It asks questions such as:

  • Who has helped previous projects gain momentum?

  • Who do community members turn to for guidance?

  • Which individuals have strong relationships across different organizations or groups?

  • Who understands the history behind current challenges?

  • Whose concerns could reveal something important that the planning team has overlooked?

  • Who is affected by the initiative but doesn't typically have access to decision-makers?

These questions can help organizations approach stakeholder engagement more intentionally.

And they can reveal relationships that might otherwise be missed.

Know the Whole Map Before You Start Navigating

Community development is rarely as simple as identifying a problem, developing a plan and securing approval.

It involves people.

History.

Relationships.

Trust.

Competing priorities.

And different understandings of what progress should look like.

Formal leadership structures provide one important part of that picture.

Informal relationships provide another.

When community leaders take time to understand both, they're better equipped to anticipate concerns, build partnerships and develop initiatives that have the support needed to move forward.

That doesn't mean every influential person will agree with every decision.

Nor should they.

But understanding the people and relationships shaping a community can help leaders approach challenges with greater awareness and make more informed decisions.

As Sarah reminds us in Episode 39:

“Know the whole map before you start navigating.”

Build Stronger Partnerships With a More Complete Community Map

At Thrive Community Partners, we help communities connect the people, priorities and resources needed to turn ideas into action.

Our free Community Action Planning Roadmap offers a practical framework for identifying key leaders, strategic partners and the relationships that can support meaningful progress.

Whether you're preparing for a new initiative, building a coalition or strengthening an existing community strategy, understanding who needs to be involved is an important place to start.

Explore the free Community Action Planning Roadmap at thrivecommunitypartners.com.

→ Start the Conversation

I'm Sarah with Thrive Community Partners. This article is based on an episode of Thrive in Five, where we share practical ideas for moving organizations and communities forward in five minutes or less.

Sarah

Sarah Stephens Krupp is the co-founder of Thrive Community Partners and a nationally recognized community development strategist with more than 20 years of experience in economic development, strategic planning, grant funding, entrepreneurship, workforce development, and organizational leadership. Throughout her career, she has helped communities secure millions of dollars in funding, led chambers of commerce, nonprofits, and economic development organizations, mentored entrepreneurs, and developed strategies that create measurable, lasting impact. Sarah is passionate about helping community leaders move from big ideas to successful implementation through practical, relationship-driven solutions.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/sarah-stephens-krupp-458683135/
Next
Next

The Power of Community Storytelling in Economic Development